Judgments on Notarial Practice
| JAYASURIA ET AL V. SINNO APPU ET AL. NLR – 65 of 16 |
| Non-notarial agreement to clear land and stack the timber-Person clearing to sow kurakkan and take all the crop-Is timber ” produce “- “Share”-OrdinanceNo.21of 1887. By a non-notarial document the defendants agreed to clear within one year a block of land’ belonging to plaintiffs and to stack all the timber-to be sawn by the plaintiffs. In return the plaintiffs agreed to allow the defendants to sow kurakkan on the land and have the produce of the same for one year. Held, that this agreement was valid though not notarially executed. |
| PERERA V. PONNATCHI NLR – 56 of 3 |
| Agreement of sale of tobacco crop-Fructus industriales-Evidence– Interest in land.A tobacco crop is fructus industrials and is not an interest in land requiring that any agreement respecting it should be notarial. |
| RATNAYAKE V. DE SILVA SLR – 57, Vol 3 of 1999 |
| Lease – Lease of land by North-Central Provincial Council – Validity – Should it be notarially attested? – Prevention of Frauds Ordinance S. 2, 17 – Provincial Councils (Consequential Provisions) Act S. 2 (1) – State land – Provincial Council List.Plaintiff-appellant instituted action seeking a declaration that the plaintiff is the lessee of the corpus. The defendant-respondent filed answer seeking a dismissal of the action on the basis that, the document (P1) upon which the plaintiff is claiming title is of no force in law. The plaintiff-appellant’s action was dismissed, |
| KIRI BANDA V. UKKU BANDA NLR – 181 of 14 |
| Evidence–Variation of a notarial instrument by anon-notarial document– Ordinance No. 14 of 1895, s. 92.There is nothing in the Evidence Ordinance to prevent a variation or modification in a notarial instrument from being proved by a subsequent non-notarial writing, provided that the latter writing is not itself of such a nature as to require notarial execution under Ordinance No. 7 of 1840. |
| LUSHINGTON V. CAROLIS ET AL., NLR – 489 of 14 |
| Security bond hypothecating land executed without notarial attestation– Obligor personally liable though hypothecation was invalid– Ordinance No. 7 of 1840, s. 2.Where a promise is entire, and is partly within and partly not within section 2 of Ordinance No. 7 of 1840, the whole contract is unenforceable unless the requirements of the section are complied with; but if the promise is divisible, so that in effect there are two distinct agreements, one of which is, and the other is not, within the section, the portion of the promise which is not within the section may be enforced, though not notarially attested.Where a security bond hypothecating immovable property was executed without notarial attestation,-Held, the informality did not relieve the obligor of his personal obligation under the bond. |
| CHARLES V. BABA ET AL., NLR – 189 of 22 |
| Agreement to pay sixteen bushels of paddy for use of certain paddy field- No notarial writing-Action to recover value of paddy-Ordinance No. 21 of 1887. Plaintiff alleged that defendant had the use and occupation of a certain paddy field promising to deliver to him sixteen bags of paddy or their value Rs. 80. Held, that as the consideration was not a share of the crop, but a certain quantity of paddy independent of what the crop should be, the action was not maintainable in the absence of a notarially executed agreement. |
| ASLIYA UMMA V. THINGAL MOHAMED SLR – 152, Vol 2 of 1999 |
| Vindicatory action – Claim for cancellation of ”fraudulent” deeds – Proof of execution of the plaintiff’s deed – Section 68 of the Evidence Ordinance – The legal effect of the failure by the Notary to observe statutory provisions applicable to the extension of a deed – Sections 31 and 33 of the Notaries Ordinance. |
| CARTHELIS V. RANASINGHE SLR – 359, Vol 2 of 2002 |
| Trusts Ordinance – Constructive Trust S. 83 – Attendant circumstances -Beneficial interests – Tests to be applied – Notaries Ordinance S. 20 (c), S. 31 (10) – Duties of a Notary. The plaintiff-respondent instituted action seeking a declaration of title to the land in question and the ejectment of the defendant-appellant. The defendant-appellant sought the dismissal of the action, and in reconvention sought an order to set aside the Deed of Transfer or in the alternative a declaration that the property is held in trust by the plaintiff-respondent. The District Court held with the plaintiff-respondent. On appeal it was contended that the trial Judge failed to consider the applicability of s. 83 Trust Ordinance. |
| DE SILVA V. DALPATADU NLR – 239 of 43 |
| Jurisdiction-Failure to transmit duplicates of deeds-Power of Magistrate to try offence under Notaries Ordinance summarily as District Judge Reason inadequate-Criminal Procedure Code, s. 152.(3). A Magistrate is not justified in trying summarily under section 152 (3) of the Criminal Procedure Code an offence under rule 25 of section 30 of the Notaries Ordinance merely because the offence is punishable with a fine of two hundred rupees. |
| EDWIN DE SILVA V. KARUNADASA DE SILVA NLR – 1 of 56 |
| Land Development Ordinance (Cap. 320)-Sections 162 and 163-Disposition of protected holding-Reference in deed to Government Agent’s consent-Imperative and not merely directory-Meaning of term “ attestation “-Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 91), s. 30 (20) and (21). Under section 162 of the Land Development Ordinance the disposition of a protected holding is vitiated by the failure of the notary to refer specifically, in the attestation clause of the deed, to the written consent of the Government Agent to the disposition. The term ” attestation ” in section 162 (1) includes both the subscription of the signature and the attestation clause. |
| FERNANDO V. FERNANDO NLR – 341 of 59 |
| Deeds-Prevention of Frauds Ordinance-Section 2-“In the presence of”-“Duly attested “-Notaries Ordinance, s. 30 (12) and (20). An instrument which is required by section 2 of the Prevention of Frauds Ordinance to be notarially attested must be signed by the Notary and the witnesses at the the same time as the maker and in his presence. Certain deeds of gift conveying lands were signed by the executant in a room in a hospital in the presence of the Notary and the witnesses, but were signed by the Notary and witnesses in a different room out of the view of the executant. Held, that the deeds were of no force or avail in law. |
| GNANAMUTTU, D.S. V. THANGIAH NLR – 354 of 55 |
| Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 91)-Breach of paragraph (a) of rule (35) in Section 30- Burden of proof. The charge against the accused was that he did ” being a notary and not being a proctor fail to live and hold office at the place approved by the Governor by warrant ” , in breach of paragraph (a) of rule (35) in section 30 of the Notaries Ordinance. Held, that there was no burden on the prosecution to prove that the accused was not a proctor. The burden was on the defence to prove that he was. |
| GUNEWARDENE V. CABRAL AND OTHERS SLR – 220, Vol 2 of 1980 |
| Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 91)-Breach of paragraph (a) of rule (35) in Section 30- Burden of proof. The charge against the accused was that he did ” being a notary and not being a proctor fail to live and hold office at the place approved by the Governor by warrant ” , in breach of paragraph (a) of rule (35) in section 30 of the Notaries Ordinance. Held, that there was no burden on the prosecution to prove that the accused was not a proctor. The burden was on the defence to prove that he was. |
| IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION OF ALBERT GODAMUNE, PROCTOR, SUPREME COURT, FOR THE ANNUAL CERTIFICATE TO PRACTICE AS NOTARY NLR – 74 of 38 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Failure to apply for annual certificate within time- Refusal of District Judge to issue certificate-No appeal-Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, s. 25 (2). No appeal lies to the Supreme Court from a decision of the District Judge under section 25 (2) of the Notaries Ordinance, refusing to issue the annual certificate to a Notary, who had failed to apply for it within the time provided by the Ordinance. |
| NADARAJAH V. REGISTRAR GENERAL NLR – 185 of 72 |
| Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 107)-Section 31, Rule 3-Whether it prohibits the signature of an incomplete duplicate.While Rule 3 of Section 31 of the Notaries Ordinance provides that a duplicate of a deed may not be signed before the original instrument is executed, it does not clearly prohibit the Notary from taking the signature-of an incomplete duplicate. |
| PATABENDI V. EDIRISURIYA AND OTHERS SLR – 162, Vol 2 of 2000 |
| Conditional Transfer – Conditions deleted in duplicate only – Attestations of original and protocol silent regarding deletions – Fraudulent conversions – Notaries Ordinance Ss.3(2), 24, S.33 – Prevention of Frauds Ordinance Ss.2, 15. 16 – Due execution and attestation – Is the duplicate a draft? |
| PEOPLES BANK V. HEWAWASAM SLR – 29, Vol 2 of 2000 |
| Declaration that Mortgage Bond is null and void – Interim Injunction restraining Bank from selling/ alienating land in Mortgage Bond – Resolution passed by Bank – Null and void? – Peoples Bank Act, No. 29 of 1961 amended by Act, No. 32 of 1986 – S 2913- Can the borrower invalidate the Resolution – Injunction – Prima facie case – Notaries Ordinance S.31(18) – S.33 – Wrong date of Execution – S.2 Prevention of Frauds Ordinance. The Plaintiff Respondent sought a declaration that the Mortgage Bond 2885 is null and void and/or has been fraudulently executed by the Defendant Petitioner (Bank) and that the Resolution passed by the Bank to ‘parate execute’ the property is null and void. The Plaintiff Respondent contended that he did not sign the Mortgage Bond, and it was never executed on 26. 01. 93. The Defendant Petitioner’s contention is that the Respondent has sought to take advantage of a mistake made by the Notary in setting out the date on the original Mortgage Bond to be 26. 01. 1993, whereas the correct date of execution which is set out in the duplicate is 26. 01. 1994. The District Court issued an interim injunction restraining the Bank from selling/alienating the land in question. Held; (1) In view of the admissions, the Plaintiff Respondent is estopped from denying the fact that the property described in Deed 10384 (Title Deed) was tendered as security. The Plaintiff Respondent has not come to court with clean hands. (2) The Defendant Petitioner has produced the Duplicate of the Bond from the Land Registry which gives the correct date of the execution as 26.01.1994.The mere fact that the Notary has inserted a false/wrong date of its execution does not render a Deed void – Provided that the Deed has been executed according to S.2 Prevention of Frauds Ordinance. (3) The provisions in S.29(D) are of similar import as “shall not be called in question in any Court”. The Resolution passed by the Bank cannot be invalidated or challenged in an action in the District Court. The sale of the mortgaged property by public auction upon the said Resolution cannot be restrained by an interim injunction. (4) The Plaintiff Respondent has failed to establish a “prima facie case.” The Plaintiff Respondent has taken advantage of a mere mistake of the date of the execution set out in the original Bond to fabricate a case to the extent of even challenging the Mortgage Bond itself. |
| PERERA V. CASSIM NLR – 33 of 40 |
| Notaries Ordinance, No. 1 of 1907-Deed of lease-Execution by lessor only-Meaning of “executed” in rule 24, s. 29-Failure to forward duplicate to Registrar-No breach of rule 24, s. 29. The failure of the notary to forward to the Registrar of Lands a duplicate of a lease executed by the lessor only does not constitute a breach of rule 24 of section 29 of the Notaries Ordinance, 1907. |
| RALIYA UMMA V. MOHAMED NLR – 385 of 55 |
| Will-Loss of original document-Presumption of destruction by testator-Protocol- Not a duplicate-Prevention of Frauds Ordinance, s. 6-Evidence Ordinance, s. 114. If a will is shown to have been in the testator’s possession, and is not forthcoming at his death, it is presumed to have been destroyed by him animo revocandi. The presumption is applicable even where the missing document is a joint will. The protocol preserved by the attesting Notary under the provisions of the Notaries Ordinance cannot be regarded as an original document capable as such of being propounded. |
| RE JAYAWARDANA NLR – 152 of 8 |
| Notary Public-Conduct of-Inquiry under s. 18 of Ordinance No. 2 of 1877 as amended by s. 2 of Ordinance No. 21 of 1900-” Offence”-” Or otherwise “-Application for writ of prohibition.Where an information was laid under section 18 of the Ordinance No. 2 of 1877 (section 2 of Ordinance No. 21 of 1900) before a District Judge that a notary public had been concerned in several criminal cases, that he was not possessed of property, that he had writs out against him, that he was keeping himself in concealment, and that he made a false affidavit in a case in which he was defendant, and when the Judge was proceeding to inquire under section 18 into the matters alleged in the information,-Held, on an application to the Supreme Court for a writ of prohibition against him, that such matters could not be the subject of inquiry under section 18, that the allegation that the notary was concerned in criminal cases, that he was not possessed of property, that there were writs of execution against him, and that he was keeping himself in concealment, were not ” offences” against any statute or other law of Ceylon; and that though giving false evidence before a competent Court was an offence against the Penal Code, yet it was not intended by the Legislature to give to the officers named in section 18 power to inquire into such offences committed by notaries outside the sphere of their duties. |
| SAMARASINGHE V. DALPATADU NLR – 564 of 41 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Conviction under rule 25, s. 30-Charge under proviso (a), s. 30-Plea of autrefois convict-Interpretation Ordinance, s. 9- Criminal Procedure Code, s. 330. The conviction of a Notary under rule 25 of section 30 of the Notaries Ordinance for failure to transmit duplicate of deeds to the Registrar of Lands is no bar to a subsequent charge against him for failure to comply with a written notice to transmit such deeds within a stated time under section 30, proviso (a) of the Ordinance. |
| SELLAMMAH V. SELLAMUTTU NLR – 376 of 59 |
| Will-Probate- Suspicions created by alterations in a will-Burden on propounder to remove them-Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 91), s. 30 (20) (21)-Prevention of Frauds Ordinance (Cap. 57), s. 7-Civil Procedure Code, ss. 524, 526. Certain obvious alterations were noticeable in a will in regard to the name of one of the devisees. The alterations were not attested or authenticated by the signatures of the notary or the testator and the witnesses in terms of either section 30 (21) of the Notaries Ordinance or section 7 of the Prevention of Frauds Ordinance. When application for probate of the will was made there was much difficulty in obtaining an affidavit from the attesting notary and witnesses. Held, that the will should not be admitted to probate in view of the failure of the propounders in the first instance to remove the suspicions created by the alterations, the knowledge of which must necessarily be imputed to them. |
| THIYAGARASA V. ARUNODAYAM SLR – 184, Vol 2 of 1987 |
| Deed-Validity-Requirement or due execution of deed-Wrong date of execution-Notaries Ordinance s 31-Deed executed pending partition case-Partition Act. s. 67(1).Held :(1) The essential elements of due execution of a deed as set out in section 2 of the Prevention of Frauds Ordinance are(a) The deed must be signed by the party making it.(b) It must be signed in the presence of a licensed notary public and two or more witnesses.(c) The notary public and the witnesses must be present at the same time.(d) The execution of the deed must be duly attested by the notary. and the witnesses. The notary is as much an attesting witness as the two witnesses themselves.(2) Where the requirements of the Prevention of Frauds Ordinance have been complied with the mere fact that the notary has inserted a false or wrong date of its execution does not render the deed void.(3) The lapse of the notary may render him liable to be prosecuted for contravention of the provisions of the Notaries Ordinance.(4) The prohibition against alienation pending partition contained in s. 67(1) of the Partition Act applies only to a partition action which” is duty registered as a lis pendens under the Registration of Documents Ordinance(5) Where the purchase pending partition was by the plaintiff himself the plaintiff cannot be permitted to take advantage of his own wrongful act. |
| WICKRAMARATNE V. CHANDRADEVA SLR – 232, Vol 2 of 1997 |
| Judicature Act, No. 2 of 1978, section 42(2) – Supreme Court Rules – Respondent has ceased to be an Attorney-at-Law – Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court to hold an inquiry – Notaries Ordinance, section 31(26) (a) – Transmission of duplicates of deeds to Registrar of Lands – Deceitful conduct – Rule absolute – Struck off the Roll proforma. One W complained to the Bar Association (BASL) on 30.08.91 that he entrusted the execution of a Deed of Partition to the Respondent C on 16.3.91 and paid Rs 20001-. It was after much delay and inconvenience that he was able to obtain the original from C. He applied to the Land Registry for a certified copy for the purpose of obtaining a Bank loan and was informed on 30.2.91 that the Duplicate had not been sent to the Land Registry. BASL fixed the matter for inquiry on 20.6.92, C by letter of 18.6.92 informed the BASL that the Deed had been misplaced and had recently been tendered to the Land Registry. W then made a further application to the Land Registry for a certified copy and was informed on 28.8.92 that the Land Registry had not received the duplicate copy of the Deed.The BASL in its report to the Supreme Court stated that the Respondent had committed acts of deceit and malpractice.At the Rule inquiry a preliminary objection was taken, that the Court had no jurisdiction to proceed as the respondent had already been removed from the office of Attorney-at-Law in S.C. Rule 1/93 on 23. 11.94.Held:(1) Section 40(1) of the Judicature Act empowers the Supreme Court in accordance with rules for the time being in force to admit and enroll as Attorney-at-Law persons of good repute and of competent knowledge and ability. Under section 42(2) Court can suspend such a person from practice or remove him from office where such person has been found guilty of any deceit, malpractice, crime or offence. In the present case it became necessary to take proceedings against this Attorney-at-Law in respect of several complaints of deceit, malpractice, crime and offence committed as an Attorney-at-Law. The jurisdiction of the Court in that regard is referable to section 40(1) under which the Court admits and enrolls a person as an Attorney-at-Law. Irrespective of the result of each such inquiry, the Court’s power to inquire into and determine every such matter continues unabated by reason of the Court having admitted and enrolled such person as an Attorney-at-Law, who at the time of admission was considered by the Court inter alia to be a person of good repute and the conduct being investigated by the Court is qua Attorney-at-Law.(2) In the matter of readmission, a practitioner’s conduct as an Attorney-at-Law which resulted in removal from the Roll is of absolute relevance. No doubt an Attorney-at-Law already removed from the Roll cannot be removed from such office several times over for other acts of misconduct warranting removal. But the Court is duty bound to investigate each such matter which has necessitated the issuance of a Rule, both in the interests of the legal profession and of the Attorney-at-Law himself, and simply because the Rule is made absolute in respect of one matter the Court does not lack jurisdiction in respect of the rest.(3) As regards the nature of the order that the Court may make in respect of an Attorney-at-Law who has already been struck off the Roll – the Court may in such a situation make the Rule absolute and direct that his name be struck off the Roll proforma |
| WICKREMANAYAKE V. PERERA NLR – 167 of 34 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Failure to renew certificate-Acting as Notary before renewal-Certificate obtained under proviso has no retrospective effect- Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, s. 25. Where a notary, who had renewed his certificate on October 14, 1931, had acted as a notary on October 2 and 6. Held that that he was rightly convicted of having acted a notary without obtaining a certificate. A certificate obtained under the proviso to section 25 of the Notaries Ordinance has no retrospective effect. |
| WIJEWARDENA AND ANOTHER VS. ELLAWALA SLR – 14, Vol 2 of 1991 |
| Last Will – Limited Probate -Probate of Will- Legal requirements for making a valid Will- Wills Ordinance section 2- Prevention of Frauds Ordinance sections 4, 10, 11, 12, 13-Notaries Ordinance sections 31, 33, 41 (2), (3)- Attesting witnesses – Civil Procedure Code sections 524, 526, 533, 534, 539 – Evidence Ordinance, section 68.No will, testament or codicil containing any devise of land or other immovable property or any bequest of movable property or for any other purpose whatsoever will be valid unless it is in writing and executed as follows: It must be signed at the foot or end thereof by the testator, or by some other person in his presence and by his direction and such signature shall be made or acknowledged by the testator in the presence of a licensed notary public and two or more witnesses who shall be present at the same time and duly attest such execution. Where one partner of a firm of Attorneys-at-law practising in partnership take the instructions of the deceased testator and later signs as a witness, the validity of the Will will remain unaffected. There is no impropriety when partners of a partnership of Attorneys‑at‑law attest the Will as witnesses and a 3rd partner attests the execution of the Will itself. Where a Will is prepared under circumstances which raise a well grounded suspicion that it does not express the mind of the testator, the Court ought not to pronounce in favour of it until that suspicion is removed. Where a will is shown to be rational and duly executed there is a presumption that the testator had testamentary capacity. The failure of the notary to seek medical opinion in regard to the competence of the testator at the time of the taking of instructions for the preparation of the Will or at the stage of execution, will not affect the validity of the will, especially where the testamentary capacity of the testator was never in issue. Non‑medical evidence to prove that the testator had a sound disposing mind can be relied on. The onus probandi lies in every case upon the party propounding a will and he must satisfy the conscience of the Court that the instrument so propounded is the last will of a free and capable testator. Where undue influence is alleged it must be proved by the party alleging it.Where the trial Judge is in gross error in regard to findings of fact the Appeal Court will interfere especially as here, the judgement was delivered long after the conclusion of the evidence. When a deed has been admitted in evidence without objection or protest and no issue was raised at the commencement of the trial or later raising the question of due execution of the deed, section 68 of the Evidence Ordinance does not require an attesting witn |
| WIJEYSURIYA V. DALPADATU NLR – 393 of 39 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Failure to transmit duplicates of deed-Duty of the Registrar-General-Failure of notary to give an explanation-Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, s. 29, Rules 24 and 33-Amending Ordinance No. 10 of 1934, s. 6 (d). The proviso to section 29 of the Notaries Ordinance does not impose an absolute duty on the Registrar-General to give a notary who has failed to transmit to the Registrar of Lands duplicates of documents in terms of rule 24, a further period of time within which he may comply with the requirements of the rule. Under rule 33 a Notary is bound to give an explanation in writing of any irregularity, error, or omission which the Registrar-General discovers or thinks he has discovered, and which appears to him to be a breach of the law. Failure to give an explanation is an offence under section 29 of the Notaries Ordinance. |
| WILISINDAHAMY V. KARUNAWATHIE AND OTHERS SLR – 136, Vol 2 of 1980 |
| Declaration of title – Notaries Ordinance, sections 31 (9) and 33 – Evidence Ordinance, section 68 – Misjoinder of parties and causes of action.Action was filed for declaration of title and ejectment of defendants by the plaintiff as administratrix of her late husband. Various incidents which took place between 1955 and 1963 were averred in the plaint. The children and husband of the first defendant were made defendants. The dispute was originally for the house and thereafter for both the house and the land. Submission was made in appeal that the notary who executed the title deed of the plaintiff failed to comply with the provisions of section 31(9) of the Notaries Ordinance. |
| M.P.MUNASINGHE V. C.P.VIDANAGE NLR – 97 of 69 |
| Appeal-Findings of fact of trial Judge-Appellate tribunal’s proper approach to them. Sale of immovable property-Consideration-Statements in attestation clause of deed- Evidential value thereof-Notaries Ordinance (Cap. 107), ss. 31, 38. The jurisdiction of an appellate court to review the record of the evidence in order to determine whether the conclusion reached by the trial Judge upon that evidence should stand has to be exercised with caution. ” If there is no evidence to support a particular conclusion (and this is really a question of law) the appellate court will not hesitate so to decide. But if the evidence as a whole can reasonably be regarded as justifying the conclusion arrived at at the trial, and especially if that conclusion has been arrived at on conflicting testimony by a tribunal which saw and heard the witnesses, the appellate court will bear in mind that it has not enjoyed this opportunity and that the view of the trial judge as to where credibility lies is entitled to great weight. This is not to say that the judge of first instance can be treated as infallible in determining which side is telling the truth or is refraining from exaggeration. Like other tribunals, he may go wrong on a question of fact, but it is a cogent circumstance that a judge of first instance, when estimating the value of verbal testimony, has the advantage (which is denied to courts of appeal) of having the witnesses before him and observing the manner in which their evidence is given.”-per VISCOUNT SIMON in Watt or Thomas v. Thomas (1947 A. C. 484 at pp. 485-6). The question at issue in the present case was whether, in an instrument which purported to be a deed of sale of immovable property, any consideration was received by the vendors. The first defendant appellant, who was one of the two vendors, claimed that there was no consideration for the deed and that no beneficial interest on the property passed to the vendee (plaintiff-respondent). The deed stated that the property was sold for Rs. 20,500 ” well and truly paid to the said vendors “. The notary’s attestation stated that the full consideration of Rs. 20,500 was acknowledged before him to have been previously received. The trial Judge, in accordance with his findings of fact, which involved assessment of the veracity of witnesses, held that no consideration passed, but the Supreme Court, on appeal, reversed the decision mainly on the basis of statements made by the notaries in their attestation of the deed in question and two other connected deeds.Held, (i) that this was a case of rather complicated and difficult facts, and there was a good deal to be said on each side. The findings, however, of the District Judge were not unreasonable and, as he had had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses giving their evidence, the Supreme Court should not have set aside his findings and consequently should not have reversed his decision. (ii) that the statements of the notary in the attestation clause of a deed of sale are admissible evidence, and may well be important evidence, regarding consideration, but are not conclusive. |
| DIAS V. RAJAPAKSE NLR – 38 of 12 |
| Notary-Practising without obtaining certificate–Annual certificate, sufficiency of–Ordinance No. 2 of 1877, ss. 22 and 24.A notary who obtains his certificate before March 1 in each year, that is, in each calendar year during which he acts as a notary, complies with the provisions of section 22 of Ordinance No. 2 of 1877, and is not liable to the penalty enacted by section 24 of the said Ordinance, |
| GUNERIS V. KARUNARATNE NLR – 47 of 18 |
| Omission on the part of notary to search for registration of seizures before drawing up conveyance-Action for damages against notary. Where a notary follows a general practice and makes a mistake regarding the strict requirements of the law as to which there is a reasonable doubt, or where he commits an error of judgment, he is not guilty of such negligence as would make him liable in damages to his client. Defendant, a notary, was sued by plaintiff for damages sustained by him by reason of omission on the part of defendant to search for registrations of seizures before drawing a conveyance of a certain parcel of land in plaintiff’s favour. Held, per PEREIRA J.-That under section 29 (16a) of the Notaries Ordinance, 1907, it was the duty of a notary, before a deed or instrument affecting land or other immovable property was drawn by him, to search or cause to be searched the registers in the Land Registry, to ascertain, inter alia, whether there were registrations of seizures (in execution) of the property dealt with by the deed or instrument, but that in the present case the defendant was not liable, because the evidence showed that the omission to search the registers for registrations of seizures was due to an error of judgment. Per DE SAMPAYO A.J.-The defendant was not bound to search for registrations of seizures under section 29 (16a) of the Notaries Ordinance, 1907. |
| IN RE THE ESTATE OF P.H. NICHOLAS HOLSINGER V. NICHOLAS NLR – 417 of 20 |
| Judicial settlement-Right of Court to inquire into charges of waste and negligence against an executor-Is separate action necessary?- Is executor entitled to charge more for proctor’s fees than what the Civil Procedure Code provides?-Notary’s fees-Executor’s remuneration-Costs. Where a complaint is made against an executor of negligence or waste, it is competent to the Court to inquire into the matter in a judicial settlement. The object of a judicial settlement is that all matters that may arise in the course of the administration of the estate between the accounting party and the beneficiary should be dealt with promptly and in an expeditious manner, so that the whole question might be finally wound up in those proceedings. If the Judge thinks that the matter is of such complication and importance that it can only be inquired into by a regular action, he might suspend the settlement until that matter is determined by a regular action, or conclude the settlement subject to the determination of that matter. Where an executor paid to the proctor, whom he employed for the purpose of the legal business of administration, a sum of Rs . 5,000, which was agreed upon in advance,- Held, that it was open to the Court to require the amount to be submitted to taxation before passing the item in the judicial settlement. Under Ordinance No. 1 of 1907 a notary is not entitled to charge a higher fee than that prescribed in the Ordinance, and an executor cannot debit the estate with a higher fee for notarial charges. The remuneration of an executor should not be a lump sum, but by a rate. |
| IN THE MATTER OF THE LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT OF KOLAMBAPATABENDIGE ABRAHAM PERERA, OF HORATUDWA, DECEASED: K. HARAMANIS PERERA AND ANOTHER, APPLICATION AND PESPONDANTS AND K. JOHANA PERERA AND ELEVEN OTHERS, RESPONDENTS AND APPELLANTS, NLR – 306 of 3 |
| Will–Execution in presence of five witnesses–Presence of notary– Validity of will–Roman-Dutch Law–Ordinance No. 7 of 1840, a. 3.Per Bonser, C.J., and Withers, J. (dissentiente Lawrie, J).- Under section 3 of Ordinance No. 7 of 1840 it is optional for an intending testator to make his will before a notary public or before five or more witnesses. The mere presence of a notary public when a will is executed before five witnesses does not render it invalid.Per Bonser, C.J.-By the law of Holland a will might be made either before a notary and two witnesses, or without a notary by a will signed by the testator and seven witnesses.By Ordinance No. 7 of 1834 the testamentary power was enlarged on the one hand and contracted on the other. It was provided that no devise of immovable property should be valid unless duly attested by a notary and two witnesses. On the other hand, a testator in extremis was allowed to make a nuncupative will in presence of two witnesses, who were to reduce it to writing and within twenty days from the death make a declaration before a notary. A will of movables signed by a testator in the presence of seven witnesses was still valid.The Ordinance No. 7 of 1840 makes no distinction between wills of movables and wills of movable property. It abolished nuncupative wills, and reduced the number of witnesses required to attest a non-notarial will from seven to five.The intention of the Legislature was to restore the option that testators had under the Roman-Dutch Law of having their wills either notarially attested or attested by witnesses.The words in section 3 of Ordinance No. 7 of 1840, ” if no notary shall be present,” mean ” if a notary shall not be present in his notarial capacity,” or, in other words, ” if the will be not attested by a notary.” |
| KING V. FERNANDO NLR – 346 of 13 |
| Notary authorized in writing to dispense with search for prior, registration-. Deed drawn up by one notary and tendered for registration by another notary-No note of prior registration made on the deed- Notary who drew up the deed not guilty of offence under s. 29 {16) of Ordinance No. 1 of 1907. Where parties to a transaction affecting land authorized a notary in writing to dispense with the search for prior registration, and the notary drew up the deed and did not note on the deed prior registration, and the deed was not tendered for registration by him,- Held, that the notary had not committed an offence under section 29 (16) of Ordinance No. 1 of 1907. The concluding words of the proviso to section 29, sub-section (16), of Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, refers only to the notary by whom a deed is tendered for registration. |
| LEE V. CHANDRAWARNAM NLR – 119 of 22 |
| Notary authorized to practise in the judicial district of Kandy-Exclusive of Nuwara Eliya-Hatton division from Kandy District-Right of notary to practise in Nuwara Eliya-Hatton division without getting his warrant altered. A notary was authorized by his warrant in 1907 to practise his profession throughout the (judicial) district of Kandy. In 1909, by Proclamation, the Nuwara Eliya-Hatton division was excluded from the judicial district of Kandy. The Registrar-General was advised by Government that the creation of the new district did not interfere with the vested rights of notaries.Held, that the notary was not entitled under his warrant to practise in the judicial district of Nuwara Eliya-Hatton., |
| PERERA V. WIJESURIYA NLR – 28 of 22 |
| Trade Marks Ordinance, No. 14 of 1888, s. 42-Use of Royal Arms by a notary on his deeds. A notary has no right by virtue of his office to use the Royal Arms on his notarial deeds. |
| QUEEN V. DE ABREW NLR – 206 of 3 |
| Duty of notary before attesting a deed–Search for registration of prior deed and noting such registration in the deed attested–Ordinances No. 2 of 1877 and No. 14 of 1891.Unless a notary has personal knowledge of the state of title in regard to a land affected by a deed which he is about to attest, he should, before attesting it, search the register at the Land Registry, either personally or by agent, to ascertain whether any prior deed affecting such land has been registered.A statement made to the notary by the grantor that there was no such deed is not sufficient, |
| QUEEN V. TILAKARATNA NLR – 208 of 3 |
| Duty of notary–Ordinance No. 2 of 1877, s. 26–Consecutive numbering of deeds as attested–Forwarding duplicates to Land Registry with list of deeds.It is the duty of a notary to number every deed consecutively according to date of attestation and to enter it in the monthly list and duplicate of the deed should be sent with such list to the Registrar of Lands as required by section 26 of Ordinance No. 2 of 1877.It is of the utmost importance for the welfare of the community that notaries should strictly comply with the duties imposed on them by law.There is a distinction between neglect and failure “: failure ” may be due to inevitable accident, ” neglect ” is a culpable omission. |
| REX V. SEENYTAMBY NLR – 367 of 26 |
| Notary–Fixing of stamps–Duplicate sent to Registrar–Wilfully false statement–Attestation clause–Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, s. 33 (d).Where a notary, who attested a deed stated in the attestation clause, as required by law, that stamps of the value of Rs. 42 were affixed to the duplicate deed, and where on receipt of the duplicate by the Registrar of Lands it was ascertained that only one stamp of the value of Rs. 2 was affixed to it.Held, that the notary was guilty of having knowingly and wilfully made a false statement in the attestation to the deed within the meaning of section 33 (d) of the Notaries Ordinance. |
| SIDAMPARAM CHETTY V. JAYAWARDENE NLR – 171 of 18 |
| Civil Procedure code, s. 337-Application for writ-Prevention of execution of decree by fraud or force-Notary practising his profession indoors-Failure to surrender his furniture. The prevention by fraud or force of the execution of a decree in order to deprive a judgement-debtor of the benefit of section 337 (a) of the Civil Procedure Code must be strictly traceable to an action done within the ten years immediately preceding the date of the application for execution. The mere fact that the debtor having assets, including household furniture, failed to surrender these to be taken in execution, or that he, being a notary, practised his profession indoors, and thus prevented arrest in execution, does not amount to such fraud or force as is Contemplated by the section. |
| SIVANADIAN V. SAMARAWIKKRAMA NLR – 221 of 3 |
| Civil Procedure code, s. 337-Application for writ-Prevention of execution of decree by fraud or force-Notary practising his profession indoors-Failure to surrender his furniture. The prevention by fraud or force of the execution of a decree in order to deprive a judgement-debtor of the benefit of section 337 (a) of the Civil Procedure Code must be strictly traceable to an action done within the ten years immediately preceding the date of the application for execution. The mere fact that the debtor having assets, including household furniture, failed to surrender these to be taken in execution, or that he, being a notary, practised his profession indoors, and thus prevented arrest in execution, does not amount to such fraud or force as is Contemplated by the section. |
| THE QUEEN V. GUNATILLEKE NLR – 187 of 2 |
| Ordinance No. 2 of 1877, s. 26, sub-sections 9, 10, and 13-Attesting unstamped deed Sealing necessary to complete attenstation–Statement in attestation as to stamp.A notary who attests a deed which by law ought to be stamped, but which bears no stamp, is guilty, under sub-section 13 of section 26 of Ordination No. 2 of 1877, of attesting a deed insufficiently stamped.The attestation of a deed by a notary is not complete when he has merely signed it, without sealing it.So, where a notary merely signed the attestation clause in a deed insufficiently stamped and stated in the clause that the duplicate bore astamp of 25 cents, whereasitbore no stamp at all, held, that he had not made himself obnoxious to sub-section 13 of section 26 of Ordinance No. 2 of 1877 for attesting a deed insufficiently stamped, nor to sub-section 10 for making a false statement as to the stamp requiredto be affixed to the duplicate. |
| WEERARATNE V. RANMENIKE NLR – 286 of 21 |
| Deed-Failure of notary to get deed executed in duplicate. The failure on the part of a notary to have a deed executed in duplicate does not affect its operation as a deed. |
| DANIEL V. COORAY NLR – 422 of 42 |
| Notary Public-Action for damages-Negligence in describing mortgaged property-Purchase of property in execution by mortgagee-Loss in consequence-Loss too remotely connected with negligence-Contributory negligence of plaintiff.The appellant, a Notary Public, was employed by the respondent to invest Rs. 1,000 on the mortgage of the northern block of a certain land belonging to one P. By an error in the appellant’s office, the southern block which was not owned by P was mortgaged instead of the northern block. The mortgagor having failed to pay interest, the bond was put in suit and at the execution sale the respondent purchased the land. At the sale the respondent was represented by another Proctor, who was authorised by the respondent to bid on his behalf. The Proctor attended the sale when the conditions of sale and a description of the property sold were read out by the auctioneer. After his purchase the respondent discovered the mistake and claimed damages. Held, that the damage sustained by the respondent was too remotely connected to the negligence of the appellant in wrongly describing the property mortgaged to entitle the respondent to succeed in his claim. Held, further, that the respondent was guilty of contributory negligence in failing to exercise proper diligence before he purchased the property. |
| KING V. CORNELIUS NLR – 300 of 32 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Having permitted or suffered party to execute document with used stamps-Proof of gualty knowledge -Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, 1. 29 (6) -Stamps Ordinance, No. 22 of 1909, s. 58 (1) (b). Where a notary public was charged under section 29 (6) of the Notaries Ordinance with having permitted or suffered parties to two deeds to execute them when they were insufficiently stamped, viz., with used stamps,- Held, the prosecution must prove that the appearance of the stamps at the time of their use was such that the notary must have known that they had been previously used or that his lack of knowledge was due to gross negligence or to wilful abstinence of knowledge. Where, on the same facts, the notary was charged under section 58 (1) of the Stamps Ordinance with having executed or signed, otherwise than as a witness, a deed chargeable with duty, without the Same being duly stamped,- Held, that he was not liable under the section because, as notary, he was only a witness to the execution of the deed. |
| KING V. PERERA NLR – 117 of 32 |
| Notaries Ordinance-Authority to practise- Live and hold office- Attestation of deeds outside office-Ordinance No. 1 of 1907, s. 29, sub-sec. (35) (a). Where a notary public received instructions and executed some deeds in a place other than that at which he lived and held office, in the area within which he was authorized to practice,- Held, that the notary did not commit a breach of sub-section (35) (a) of section 29 of the Notaries Ordinance, No. 1 of 1907. |
| KING V. SENEVIRATNE NLR – 138 of 6 |
| Notary Public-Original and duplicate of deeds-Neglect to state in the attestation clause the erasures, &c, made in the duplicate of the deed– Ordinance No. 21 of 1900, s. 3 (22).It being provided in sub-section 22 of section 3 of Ordinance No. 21 of 1900 that it is the duty of a notary to. state ” definitely the erasures, alterations, or interpolations which have been made in such deed, “- Held, that the term ” such deed” applies to not only the original but also the duplicate, and that the notary is responsible for any omission in the duplicate of the formalities required by sub-section 22, just as he would be for a similar omission in the original. |
DE SILVA AND OTHERS v.SENEVIRATNE AND ANOTHER-1981-2-SLLR 7
IN RE RULE AGAINST ATTORNEY AT LAW 1998-3 SLLR-25
Noor Nazima Vs Shantha Wimalasuriya Tilakaratne-SC. Appeal No. 93-2009
AMERASEKERA-v.-RAJAPAKSE 14 NLR 110
Vairamuttu Palagapodi Vs Gnanamuttu Kanmani-C.A. Case No. 201-1998 (F)
Jayasinghe Arachchige Percy Hubert Vs. Kadupitige Jennie Muriel Perera C.A. No. 644 / 96 (F)
DE SILVA AND OTHERS v.SENEVIRATNE AND ANOTHER-1981-2-SLLR 7
EMALIA-FERNANDO-Appellant-and-CAROLINE-FERNANDO-and-others-Respondents 59 NLR 341
HEMATHILAKE-v.-ALLINA-AND-OTHERS 2003-2 SLLR 144
IN RE RULE AGAINST ATTORNEY AT LAW 1998-3 SLLR-25
IN-RE-AMARASINGHE-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 1981-1 SLLR 384
IN-RE-ARTHENAYAKE-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 1987-1 SLLR314
IN-RE-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 2007-1 SLLR 357
IN-RE-UPALI-WIJESURIYA-AN-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 1981- 1 SLLR 178
IN-THE-MATTER-OF-RULE-AGAINST-AN-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 2008 1 SLLR 275
NIZAM-v.-MUSTAFFA 1981 1 SLLR 58
PREMAWATHI-V-GNANAWATHI 1994 2 SLLR 171
RANASINGHE-v.-SOMALIN-AND-OTHERS 2000- 2 SLLR 225
RAOHAN-DE-SOYZA-v.-JINENDRADASA 2004-1 SLLR 379
RULE-AGAINTS-AN-ATTORNEY-AT-LAW 2008- 2 SLLR 73
SCAppeal7_04FraudInDeed1_07.05.2009
THAMBIPILLAI-and-others-Appellants-and-A.-MUTHUCUMARASAMY-and-others-R 28 NLR
THISA-NONA-AND-THREE-OTHERS-v.-PREMADASA 1997-1 SLLR
THIYAGARASA-v.-ARUNODAYAM 1987- 2 SLLR
WIJEYARATNE-AND-ANOTHER-v.-SOMAWATHIE 2002- 1 SLLR